The Gods of Gotham by Lyndsay Faye – Book Review

gods of gotham picture

gods of gotahm pictureTimothy Wilde begins 1845 with a lucrative position as a bartender in a booming restaurant located near the New York Stock Exchange. He nurses twin passions in his love for his beautiful childhood friend Mercy (whom he hopes to marry), and an abiding hatred of his older brother Valentine (for reasons that are initially unclear).Wilde’s dreams go up in flames when a fire destroys his job, home, and face. Disfigured and in need of work, he takes a position as police officer in the newly minted New York Police Department. Settling into his new line of work isn’t easy- the job was finessed by his brother-  and he almost gives it up, but then he runs into a young girl covered in blood. Tim finds he can’t walk away until he uncovers her secrets and the city’s.

In The Gods of Gotham, Lyndsay Faye does an incredible job of immersing the reader into 1845 New York. She deftly portrays the passionate and determined people, the battles for survival and dominance among the immigrant population, and the religious unrest between Catholics and Protestants- at an all-time high with the large increase of the Irish population surrounding The Great Famine. It is all threatening to erupt into an uncontrollable mess. These days, no matter what we think about police officers, they are an established and essential part of our society. Not so at the time. It was fascinating to see the development of the police force, and the way it was initially viewed as an encroachment on freedom – akin to having a standing army in New York. Though police forces had been established in Europe and other American cities, New York, as filthy and violent as it was, was a hold out. Faye’s account of the force’s early days and her inclusion of the lexicon of the city’s poor and/or criminal element was eye-opening. The characters in charge of running the city, and the methods they employed, were just as colorful as those of the criminal element they sought to control.

The language in The Gods of Gotham takes some getting used to as a lot of the characters speak “flash”. Some maneuvering back and forth with the lexicon and explanation by other characters is required, but Faye manages to use it in a balanced way that only adds to the richness of the story. Her characterizations of Timothy, Valentine, Bird and Mercy are fully realized and each of their stories, backgrounds and choices are like paint coloring in the details of hardscrabble lives, religious and moral strife, and the exacting requirements of big city living. She truly recreates the feel of mid-nineteenth century New York, and the novel is just as much astute historical perspective and analysis as it is a solid and entertaining murder mystery. Highly Recommended.

Read More Reviews At: Booking MamaDevourer of Books

1DA652C2516038AE4D02F55645591F39 From The Memoirs of A Non Enemy Combatant by Alex Gilvarry   Book Review

Review Copy.

You may also like


  1. This book sounds wonderful. I love reading about New York City’s past and am intrigued about the time when there was a large influx of the Irish. I always love a good murder mystery, too and I think it’ll be fascinating to reading about the growth and development of the NYPD! This book has so much to offer! Thank you for a fantastic review, Nicole, you’ve hooked me!

    Your review reminds me that I want to try to get a copy and read it so I can join your Book Club discussion since I forgot to sign up on time.

  2. I just listened to an interview with this author and straight away went to my library website to request it. Now I just have to wait (im)patiently for it to come in from the supplier!

  3. I am just starting this one, and it sounds like I am going to love it. The plot and style sound very interesting, and I love that you mention the dialect. Now I won’t be surprised when that crops up! Great review today! I can’t wait to discuss this one!

  4. I read this book when it first came out. I downloaded it to my Kindle. Unfortunately, it did not come with the flash dictionary that I heard is in the physical book. I really did not have a hard time following it. I was engrossed with faye’s writting style. You really get a great feel of NYC in the 1840’s. There are so many twists and turns that I just could put the book down. I hear Faye is currently writting the sequel and I can’t wait to read it. By far, this the best book I have ever read. I can’t believe that Faye has only written 2 books. I also read the first one ‘Dust and shadow’ and loved that as well. I think ‘Gods of Gotham’ is her best work so far. She is such a talented writer and writes like a very experienced novelist. I highly reccomend this book. It is the greatest. If she doesn’t get some kind of award for this work I will be so disapointed!