Peony In Love: A Novel, Lisa See – Book Review

peony-in-lovePeony in Love, by Lisa See
Publisher: Random House
Format: 284 pages/Hardcover

Somehow, Snow Flower and the Secret Fan made it into my collection of tbr and I loved the beautiful story of friendship and sacrifice, and the now lost art of nushu (secret women’s writing). I finally got around to reading Peony In Love and I wasn’t disappointed.  Lisa See knows how to weave a story full of richness and historical accuracy that is hard to put down.

“Two days before my sixteenth birthday, I woke up so early that my maid was still asleep on the floor at the foot of my bed.  I should have scolded Willow, but I didn’t because I wanted a few moments alone to savor my excitement.”

Peony is young woman from a wealthy family in Ming Dynasty China about to be married to a man she has never met but whose father had been a good friend to her own father.  Though her mother does not approve, Peony is allowed to attend an opera, The Peony Pavilion, in the garden of the Cheng Family Villa on the eve of her sixteenth birthday, which her father is presenting to curry favor with powerful business interests.  There she meets a man who will change her life and set her on a journey where she learns about love and relationships, betrayal and sacrifice, and women and their place and voice in society.

It took me awhile to get into the story.  Not because the language wasn’t lush and beautiful, or because the story wasn’t engaging, but in the beginning I was lost trying to keep up with what was going on in the opera along the introduction of multiple characters, and all their theories and trains of thought early in the novel.  I was having a hard time keeping it straight and I didn’t think I was going to make it through.  The opera is a fairly central piece of the story and I was confused about its theories of love and the afterlife.  There was also the aspect of adjusting to a different culture.  As usual the foot binding scenes leave me very squeamish. But, with a little bit of patience with the first the first few chapters, this book unfolds into a wonderful and rich story, and I learned so much about women writers in ancient times and how they were allowed to step forward and be heard in a unique period in history.

See’s attention to the details of the culture are astounding and once I was able to adjust to all that was going on I was riveted and couldn’t turn the pages fast enough.  See (no pun intended!) an example:

“On the second night, when the Manchus slaughtered our servants in the main courtyard, my husband reminded and his concubines that we were to safeguard our chastity with our lives and that all women should be prepared to make sacrifices for their husbands and sons.  The concubines were still concerned with the fate of their gowns, powders, jewels and ornaments, but your mother and I did not need to hear this admonition.  We knew our duty.  We were prepared too do the correct thing.”

I know that I will be reading the rest of her work!

Read More Reviews At:

Book Escape

Hello, My Name is Alice

Book Addiction

Have you read Peony In Love? Please e-mail me your link or leave it in the comments, I’d love to have it here.

You may also like


  1. Hi Nicole & Alice!
    Thanks for stopping by and leaving your links. I really enjoyed both your reviews and have edited my post to include them. I hope you don’t mind. 🙂
    Nicole, I too didn’t really care for the fact that it was a ghost story in the beginning, but I came around. Peony grew so much and it was interesting to watch.
    Alice, I really loved the history of the opera once I was able to start wrapping my brain around it. It is always so amazing to me, the things we learn about the past and the lives people led and what they were able to accomplish.

  2. Pingback: Bookkeeping~ September/ October | Linus's Blanket
  3. Pingback: The Year That Was ~ November 2009 | Linus's Blanket