Penelopiad, Margaret Atwood – Book Review



The Penelopiad, Margaret Atwood
Fiction, 196 pages, Hardcover
Publisher: Canongate
Publication Date: 2005

I picked up this book while browsing at the library during lunchtime (that is quickly becoming my latest addiction).  I already have copies of Oryx and Crake, Alias Grace, and The Blind Assassin by Margaret Atwood at home; but of course I couldn’t read those, I had to bring home something else.  This is why I have about 400 books in my personal library and have read less than a third of them.  I go to the library, things look interesting, I pick them up.  People give me books to read (one of my co-workers has given me a second book to read (yay!) in as many weeks), and then I wander into bookstores and can’t help myself and on top of that can’t buy one thing.  Apparently books have that in common with Lays!  But, I digress.

I remember reading the Odyssey and thinking of Penelope being the smart, beautiful, industrious, long suffering wife of Odysseus. I was expecting that The Penelopiad would have been Penelope’s story, but I guess maybe it wasn’t her story in the way that I wanted to hear it.  In this story she constantly keeps her opinions to herself in order to keep the peace and allows herself to be manipulated by her mother-in-law and a faithful old servant of Odysseus. Atwood portrays Penelope as an uncertain teenager who has ideas and thoughts in her head that she can’t articulate to others, and because  of this can’t take control of her destiny.  She wanders friendless around the palace and lets the servant have dominion over her son Telemachus.  As I think about it now, Penelope has the voice of a teenager (and she is only  15 when she and Odysseus marry), which might explain a lot of her choices but for the fact that she writes it as a dead woman who has had thousands of years to reflect on her life.

Told in flashback, we begin with Penelope living in the Underworld where she has run-ins with her rival, Helen of Troy, the suitors who plagued her in Odysseus’s absence, and her twelve maids whom were hanged by her son Telemachus at Odysseus’s request.  Throughout her tale she offers commentary on the changes that have taken place in the world since her death, like what surprises her and how the living won’t leave the dead alone (she gets conjured up through séances).   These tangents I think, are meant to be cute and to provide Penelope with a hip and modern voice, but I found all the asides to be extraneous and distracting and they take up too much of the book.

Penelope’s voice as a character is in places witty, interesting and humorous; she’s a pretty smart cookie but I would have liked to see that displayed more in the narrative.  More focus seem to be devoted to her insecurities around Helen, and how lost she is without Odysseus. But, I laughed out loud when she talks about her misgivings on spending time with her father after he has tried to drown her in the river as a baby when a seer said that she would have something to do with the making of his shroud.

“I found this affection difficult to reciprocate.  You can imagine.  There I would be, strolling hand in hand with my apparently fond male parent along a cliff edge or a river bank or a parapet, and the thought would occur to me that he might suddenly decide to shove me or bash me to death with a rock.  Preserving a calm façade under these circumstances was a challenge.  After such excursions I would retire to my room and dissolve in flood of tears.”

That was good stuff!

Unfortunately Penelope got lost in the retellings of other people’s stories.  Her story is everyone else’s story but her own, and I considered given this is Atwood the commentary that she is making on women’s lives and how they make their choices.  I can see that, but I am a disappointed because Penelope’s mythology seems so different than the weepy woman who is often times telling this story.  Dead and buried, Penelope is still jealous of Helen of Troy. Even Atwood didn’t think Penelope had all that much to say.  With a title like The Penelopiad I was expecting something a bit more substantial than 196 pages, and the print was huge!  So this was very short; easily read in an afternoon. If I had it to do over, this is one by Atwood I’d probably skip.

Read this book? Send me a link and I will post your thoughts too!

You may also like


  1. I absolutely love the idea of writing a book from Penelope’s perspective — and this sounds like it has some twists I wouldn’t expect. Thanks for a great review.

  2. Last summer I read The Odyssey followed directly by The Penelopiad. I hated it. My reaction was very strong and immediate. Atwood’s Penelope was completely different than the Penelope of Homer. At least I was a short read.